Opinion · · Peter Hogg
Train 32N and the Importance Real-Time Monitoring
The National Transportation Safety Board’s thorough and revealing investigation report into the February 3, 2023 rail disaster at East Palestine Ohio found the train’s failure and consequent high risk to humans, wildlife and environment could have been avoided at relatively little cost through the adoption of available technology.
Stripped to its essentials, the NTSB’s analysis proves beyond dispute that the collapse of over-heating bearing – in fact, “within the reconditioned bearing had evidence of melting’[1]– wheel bearings triggered the series of events that will be seen as a turning point in the safety measures that US freight rail may be forced to adopt in the future.
Under the safety measures of the time, the crew did everything right by slowing and preparing to stop the train for an inspection of the hot axle after they received an alarm, but still the catastrophe occurred. The salient point is worth repeating: the presence of no less than three of these detectors failed to m ake a difference.
The consideration of the merits of real-time monitoring have been identified during the hearing[2]. In particular, all major hearing representatives across the industry agreed that if a real-time monitoring safety system had been in place, it would have prevented the disaster. At Transdiagnostics, the company of which I am a Founder, we have proven the value of seamless, all-of-train, real-time monitoring over a four-year trial which began in July 2020, providing endless and reliable data feeds. Called Transend, the system is based on sensors that provide crews with what can be described as a non-stop reading of the state of the train. Infrastructure assets such as switches are also monitored.
In this way the entire train is digitally connected through sensors that never sleep. In what we call the Connected Railroad,the train crew and despatcher always know the precise and current state of all the vital components. (Sensors also alert all parties including maintenance long before a failure is even likely to occur. This is important because maintenance failures often trigger running failures.)
None of this is revolutionary, except in rail throughout the world. Aircraft are monitored from air to ground in real time 24 /7, hence the location of every plane is always available. Mining and shipping deploy sensors in engine rooms and other mission -critical areas. And the oil and gas industry has used sensors for years on oil rigs, refineries and energy hubs. Quite simply, real-time monitoring is seen as essential and best practice in safety management.
Given the high risk, cost and disruption of events such as the derailment of trains hauling toxic materials, we consider it extraordinary that real-time monitoring is not mandatory. Compared with the consequences, real-time monitoring is extremely cost-effective.
The founders of Transdiagnostics have worked widely across the rail industry and having seen the damage caused by avoidable failures, we believe the introduction of the Connected Railroad is inevitable in the interests of the crew, rail company and public.
[1] NTSB Mechanical Group Factual report DCA23HR001 Group B exhibit 5 p 18 [2] House Transportation Committee Hearing On East Palestine Train Derailment July 23,2024